When did micah become a rat

For anyone who likes reading my thoughts on the many things I write about and not minding hearing spoilers, please continue on and enjoy.

Log In Sign Up. What do you need help on? Cancel X. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. Canderous87 posted

When did micah become a rat

Log In Sign Up. What do you need help on? Cancel X. Topic Archived Page 1 of 2 Last. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. UnfairRepresent 5 years ago 1. The entire game foreshadows that Micah is the rat. Then attempts to mislead you with Molly but Arthur don't fall for it because he's so smart But Milton reveals that Micah only squealed after Guarma And I see no reason why he would lie in that situation. He was about to kill Arthur he'd either not lie or not say anything.

Log In Sign Up. If you know about Abigail origins then you will know she was thief and pros brought by uncle in the gang and literally abused by everyone. Store Page.

Well according to Milton, They picked up Micah when they returned from Guarma, and i think that Micah ratted out the gang because he was afraid he would be killed if he didn't. This is also backed up by the fact that Micah seems to rather enjoy being in the gang, and even feels like he betrayed them after he was arrested in Strawberry. Why did he become a rat? While the rest of the gang brush it off, Micah may have kept it in mind, knowing that it might come in useful one day. By the time the five gang members had returned from Guarma, it was clear that Dutch was going mad and that the gang was on its last legs. Furthermore, it had reached the point where Dutch placed full trust in him, so there would be little chance of being discovered.

I mentioned this in an earlier reply. They are resourceful enough to find out via other means. In all chapters, it appears that the gang are being watched more closely than they think, and this is very plausible in chapter 4. The whole theme of the game is that the West is dying and forces in support of civilisation i. Assuming Micah was a rat before Guarma, then he couldn't have worked with the Pinkerton's directly, due to Milton's comment.

When did micah become a rat

Well according to Milton, They picked up Micah when they returned from Guarma, and i think that Micah ratted out the gang because he was afraid he would be killed if he didn't. This is also backed up by the fact that Micah seems to rather enjoy being in the gang, and even feels like he betrayed them after he was arrested in Strawberry. Why did he become a rat? While the rest of the gang brush it off, Micah may have kept it in mind, knowing that it might come in useful one day. By the time the five gang members had returned from Guarma, it was clear that Dutch was going mad and that the gang was on its last legs. Furthermore, it had reached the point where Dutch placed full trust in him, so there would be little chance of being discovered. He wanted to torment Arthur about Micah being the rat before killing him, so he would give him the full details of it. In essence, why would he lie? Admittedly, the Blackwater ferry robbery is perhaps a cause for suspicion regarding his true loyalties, but it could perhaps be because it would be such a big take and that it may result in a massive shootout, which Micah always enjoys.

Washable rug runners

He finally saw how much he lost with his decisions when Arthur died, and then betrayed Micah at the end as well. Captain this. Explore Wikis Community Central. Date Posted: 2 May, pm. A popular theory among fans of the game is that Micah had intentions to implode the gang from the inside long before being caught by the Pinkertons after the gang escaped the Plantation Revolution in Guarma. Story ideas for a RDR 3. Why is there even debate about this? Everytime I launch the game, the Rockstar Games Launcher starts updating He was a narcissist that had to stay in power over the gang above everything else, and believed he was in complete control until it was way to late. Why would she put John and her son for that matter in that kind of danger? I think him wearing white was his way of having the Pinkertons and the Law not shoot at him. He became a rat after Guarma. Originally posted by JuiceWSA :. Maybe she was trying to convince John to escape and Since John was loyal man, She could never made him convinced him.

Red Dead Redemption 2 released in to great critical reception and saw tremendous sales success. The game told a Western tale that ended up being one of the best video game narratives of all time as players journeyed along the way with Arthur Morgan.

I hated Micah the most on my first playthrough, but really blame Dutch for most everything now. Micah is seen with a wanted poster for Dutch. Story ideas for a RDR 3. Which He refused. SeekAndDestroy2 5 years ago Milton diffused this by calling Micah the rat. UnfairRepresent Topic Creator 5 years ago 6. Posts: Sounds more like you're jaded from being hurt by women, and that sucks majorly. Canderous87 5 years ago 28 Ganon posted He was never the rat. The only option was left to rat out the gang as an exchange of Her family immunity. And if she cared about John, there were a lot of situations in the game where he could've easily been killed if she was indeed a Pinkerton informant. In the epilogue, when you get the Blackwater loot, she doesn't even want to hear about it and screams at John for even taking it back with him.